Prioritize HSE Maturity Indices (Case Study: Sarkhon and Qeshm Refinery Companies)

Document Type : Original Article


1 M.A. Student, University of Hormozgan.

2 Assistant Professor, University of Hormozgan.

3 M.Sc., Amir Kabir University, Head of the Department of Safety, Health and Environment, Sarkhon and Qeshm Refinery.


Today's organizations are in a world that is sensitive to social and environmental issues, and it is necessary to give special attention to the health and well-being of employees, as well as environmental protection, in addition to customer satisfaction. The purpose of this study is to determine the weight of each of the HSE maturity indices for oil and gas industries. The statistical population of the study consisted of HSE experts and experts in Sarkhon and Qeshm Refinery Company. HSE maturity indicators have been identified through semi-structured interviews with the organization's experts and the experimental data of the research. To determine the importance of dimensions and indicators, a combination of fuzzy DEMATEL and fuzzy ANP techniques have been used. The results showed that the dimensions of strategy and line with score of 97, evaluation and risk management with a score of 85 and leadership, commitment and culture with the score of 80 first to third priorities, and in the results section, the safety dimensions with a score of 172, health with score 142 and environmentalists rated 137 with the first to third priority. Finally, the HSE maturity level of Sarkhon and Qeshm gas refining companies was measured using the weights earned in the research, with 80.2% of the total points ranked 3rd (growth level).


1.Adab, Hossein, Golavar, Morteza (2013). Evaluation of Organizational Excellence of Iranian National Gas Company based on EFQM model edited 2010. Scientific-Research Paper on Management Studies. Number 70. 25-46(In Persian)
2.Ahmadvand, Ali Mohammad, Na'imi, Na'im (2011). Designing the Excellence Framework for HSE System by Khatam-ol-Anbia Construction Foundation with the EFQM Approach. Master's Thesis, Shahed University. (In Persian)
3.Alizadeh, Seyyed Shams al-Din; Taghdisi, Mohammad Hussein (2009). HSE Culture Engineering. Rayhan Publishers
4.Asgharizadeh, Ezzatollah; Ghasemi, Ahmad Reza; Jafarzadeh, Mohammad Taghi; Behrooz, Mohammad Sadegh (2012). Assessment and ranking of optimal safety management system. Journal of Industrial Management Perspective. 103-124. (In Persian)
5.Azadeh, A. Mohammad Fam, I., & Azamzadeh, M. (2009). Integrated HSEE
management systems for industry: A Case Study in Gas Refinery, Journal of the Chinese Institute of Engineers, 32(2), 235-241.
6.Azadeh, A., Fam, I.M., Khoshnoud, M. and Nikafrouz, M. (2008). Design and
implementation of a fuzzy expert system for performance assessment of an
integrated health, safety, environment (HSE) and ergonomics system: The case of a gas refinery, Information Sciences, 178(22), 4280–4300.
7.Azadeh, A., Gaeini, Z., & Moradi, B., (2014). Optimization of HSE in Maintenance Activities by Integration of Continuous Improvement Cycle and Fuzzy Multivariate Approach: A Gas Refinery. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries.
8.Azizi, Zahra, Omidvari, Manouchehr, Jozzi, Seyyed Ali (2013). A Model for HSE Audit on Petroleum Loading Platforms. The 10th International Industrial Engineering Conference. Volume 10. Number
9.Baharlouei, Mehdi, Salehi, Mojtaba (2017). Evaluation of HSE Performance Management Performance Indicators in the Viewpoint of ARAS-G Method Case Study: Homa Industry Co., First Conference on Management, Applied Economics and Business. Article 1, Number 1. (In Persian)
10.Cambon J, Guarnieri F, & Groeneweg J. (2006). Towards a new tool for measuring safety management system performance. Learning from Diversity: Model-based Evaluation of Opportunities for Process (Re)-Desing and Increasing Company Resilience
11.Chen, K. &Khan, f. (2017). Safety assessment of natural gas purification plant. To appear in: Process Safety and Environment Protection.
12.Dar Mohammadi Ali; Mohammadfam; Iraj; Zarei, Ismail (2015). Application of an Applied Model for Assessing the Performance of HSE Contractors in Construction. Iran's Occupational Health Schedule. 13th issue. 6. (In Persian)
13.Farshad, Ali Asghar, Khosravi, Yahya, Alizadeh, Seyyed Shamsuddin (2006). The role of HSE management system in improving the health, safety and environmental performance of organizations and sustainable development. Iranian Journal of Health, Vol. 3 No. 3
14.Ghasemi, Ahmad Reza (2014). The H3SE model is presented in line with the sustainable development of petrochemical industries. Tehran University of Technology, Department of Management, No. 6, Number 384-361. (In Persian)
15.Heidari, Mohammad Hassan, Ali Asghar Farshad and Shiraze Arghami, 2002, Investigation of the relationship between safety and safe behaviors among the employees of the production line of one of the metal industries of Arak city, National Conference on ergonomics in industry and production, Tehran, ergonomics association and human factors engineering. (In Persian)
16.Hosseinpoor, Sha'ban Ali, Razmi, Jafar, Ghazizadeh, Ali (2013). Prioritizing Effective Parameters in Promoting Health, Safety and Environment (HSE-MS) Using Fuzzy Logic and Quality House (Master's thesis), Payam Noor University, Shemiran Center. (In Persian)
17.Hou X. The Effective Contractor Management in International Oil
Cooperation. Asia Pacific Health, Safety, Security and Environment Conference. Jakarta, Indonesia, 4-6 August 2009.
18.Jabbari, Muossa, Alijunzadeh, Mostafa, Vaziri, Mohammad Hossein, Rahimi, Somayeh (2014). Validation of the HSE Culture Assessment Tool in a Manufacturing Company. Iran Health Report. 11. Number 4. (In Persian)
19.Jafari, Mohammad Javad, Mappar, Mahsa, Mansouri, Nabiallah (2012). The HSE ranking model for contractors before contract is based on contract level. Journal of Occupational Health, Vol. 10, No. 2
20.Jafarnejad Khaghushi, Ahmad, Kazemi, Aaliyah, Arab, Alireza (2016). Identifying and prioritizing suppliers' resilience assessment indicators based on the best-worst-case method. Journal of Industrial Management Perspective. 23. 159-186. (In Persian)
21.Knode T, & Cook P. (2004). Evaluation of Contractors HSE Performance Based on Lagging Indicators: Is there a better way. International Society of
Petroleum Engineers (SPE).
22.Li,W. Liang, W., Zhang, L., & Tang, Q.(2015). Performance assessment system of health, safety and environment based on experts' weights and fuzzy comprehensive evaluation. Journal of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries, 35 95-103.
23.Mahmoudi, Shahram, Nasiri, Parvin, Mohammadfam, Iraj (2015). A model for choosing contractors from the perspective of HSE. Journal of Occupational Health Engineering. Volume 3. Number 3. (In Persian)
24.Masine Asl, Hamed (2010). The Maturity Model of Safety Management, Health and Environment in Petrochemical Industries Projects. Master's Thesis. Tehran Payam Noor University. (In Persian)
25.Mearns, K. Ivar, J. (2003).Occupational health and safety and the balanced scorecard. The TQM Magazine, 15(6), 408-423.
26.Mengolini A, Debraberis L. (2008). Effectiveness evaluation methodology for safety processes to enhance organisational culture in hazardous installations. Journal of Hazadous Materials, 243-252
27.Ministry of Oil of Iran (2005), "Regulations on Safety, Health and Environment of the National Iranian Oil Company", Tehran.
28.Mitroff, I., & Anagnos, G. (2005). Managing crises before they happen: What every executive and manager needs to know about crisis management. New York, NY: Amacom.
29.Mitroff, Yin Yang Wangnas, Kas. (2001). Crisis Management Before it's happening, what a manager and an executive should know about crisis management. Translation of Mahmoudtotunchian. Higher Education and Research Institute of Management and Planning.
30.Mohammad Fam, Iraj; Shekari, Amir; Khosrowjerdi, Amir Hossein (2008). A model for measuring the performance of the HSE system based on EFQM excellence. Science and technology is environmentally. Article 10. Number 4.
31.Mohammadfam, Iraj, Kamalienia, Mojtaba, Golmohammadi, Rostam, Momeni, Mansour, Hamidi, Soltanian, Alireza. (2016). A framework for evaluating the performance of occupational safety and health management systems using multivariate decision-making methods. Iranian Journal of Health Surveying. No. 14. Number 1. (In Persian)
32.Mohammadfam, Iraj; Shokoohipoor, Amir; Zaman Parvor, Alireza (2016). Provide a model for assessing the risk of intentional fire-fighting. Journal of Occupational Health Engineering. Number 1. Page 25-16. (In Persian) 33.Omidvrai, M., & Lashgary, Z. (2014). Presenting a model for safety program performance assessment using grey system theory. Grey Systems: Theory and Application, 4(2), 287-298.
34.Padash A., Khodaparast M., Zahirian A., & Kaabi Nejhadian A. (2011). Green sustainable Island by implementation of environmental. Health, Safety and
Energy Strategy in KISH Trading-Industrial Free Zones-IRAN, World Renewable Energy Congress 2011 (pp. 3034-3041), Linkuping: Linkuping University, Retrieved May 8-11.
35.Ramli, A.A., & Watada J, (2011). Pedrycz W. Possibilistic regression analysis of influential factors for occupational health and safety management systems. Safety science. 49(8), 1110-7.
36.Ravahanast, Kazem, Aghajani, Hasanali, Safai Khodaikhali, Abdolhamid; Yahyazadefar, Mahmoud (2017). Determination and Weighting of Resiliency Strategies in the Iran Khodro Supply Chain. Journal of Industrial Management Perspective, 25, 145-172. (In Persian)
37.Sawacha E, Naoum S, & Fong D. (1999). Factors affecting performance on construction sites. International Journal of Project Management, 17(5), 309-315.
38.Shafaii Gholami, Pari, Nasiri, Parvin, Yarahmadi, Rasool, Hamidi, Abdol Amir, Mirkazemi, Roxana (2013). Investigating the HSE Performance of Contractors Based on Key Indicators in Petrochemical Industries. Iranian Journal of Health. Issue 11 No. 3.
39.Shahibandarzadeh, Hamid; Saeedi, Farid (2012). Identifying and determining the importance of the organization's readiness for implementation of process re-engineering using DEMATEL method and the process of group network analysis with a fuzzy approach. Investigation into operations and its applications. First issue, 17-17. (In Persian)
40.Shamsi, Azin; Omidvari, Manouchehr; Hosseinzadeh Lotfi, Farhad (2016). A Model for Measuring the Performance Indices of HSE Units in the Melting Industry. Health Indicator of Iran. Period 14. Number. (In Persian)
41.Shaw, G. K. (2010). A risk management model for the tourism industry in South Africa, Thesis submitted for the degree Doctor of Philosophy in Tourism Management at the Potchefstroom Campus of the North-West Dr. M. Saayman and Dr. A. Saayman
42.Vosoughi, Shahram; Dana, Touraj; Serajzadeh, Narges. (2016). Presenting an Audit Model of the HSE-MS Management System for the Printing Industry with the ANP and Dimetal Model with an Emphasis on Audit Methods (D & S, MISHA, and OGP) Case Study: Institute of Information Technology and Iran Printing Company. Journal of Health, Vol. 12, No. 3. (In Persian)
43.Yan, L., Zhang, L., Liang, W., Li, W., & Du, M. (2017). Key factors identification and dynamic fuzzy assessment of health, safety and environment performance in petroleum enterprises. (Vol. 94)
44.Yarahmadi, Rasol, Shakouhi, Farzaneh-al-Sadat; Taheri, fereshte; Moradi, Parvin (2014). Prioritization of Occupational Health and Safety Management Indicators in Construction Industry Based on Multi-Criteria Decision Making. Journal of Occupational Health, Vol. 12, No. 6.